(real-Life Puzzle) -- in a movie, a guy is on the phone,

[HenHanna]

in a movie, a guy is on the phone, and the person (on the other end)
(often a woman) hangs up

I've always felt that this happens 100+ times more
often in movies than in real life...

THEN the guy goes ...

--------- Hello? Hello? Susan? Are you there?
----------------- Did you just hang up on me?

I've always felt that this happens 1000+ times more
often in movies than in real life....


in Older movies, the guy does that [momentary Hang-up] thing.
---------- In older times, this didn't hang up?

[Mike Terry]

in a movie, a guy is on the phone,  and the person (on the other end)
(often a woman)  hangs up
                    I've always felt that this happens 100+ times more
                                   often in movies than in real life...
THEN the guy goes ...
                   --------- Hello?  Hello?  Susan?   Are you there?
                      ----------------- Did you just hang up on me?

That doesn't make sense - at least the guy needs to call her back again before the last line!

I think more common is guy turning to someone nearby and announcing (in amazed tone) "She hung up on
me!!!" I've never seen anyone do that in real life. :)

 I've always felt that this happens 1000+ times more
               often in movies than in real life....
in Older movies, the guy does that  [momentary Hang-up] thing.
                        ---------- In older times,  this didn't hang up?

In the UK, phones (standard land line) break the connection when the /caller/ hangs up. The called
party can put the phone down then pick it up and continue the conversation. Given the myriad
possible abuses this system invites, I find it hard to believe that is really how it works, but it
is. I don't think people deliberately use this feature (e.g. what you call [momentary Hang-up])
apart from certain scammers. Perhaps you're thinking of offices who would be on private exchanges
where callers can be put on hold? Or just phones with a mute button?

Anyhow, VOIP and mobile phone calls can be terminated by either party. Much more sensible/secure.

Mike.

[HenHanna]

Post by Mike Terry

in a movie, a guy is on the phone,  and the person (on the other end)
(often a woman)  hangs up
                    I've always felt that this happens 100+ times more
                                   often in movies than in real life...
THEN the guy goes ...
                   --------- Hello?  Hello?  Susan?   Are you there?
                      ----------------- Did you just hang up on me?

That doesn't make sense - at least the guy needs to call her back again before the last line!
I think more common is guy turning to someone nearby and announcing (in amazed tone) "She hung up on
me!!!" I've never seen anyone do that in real life. :)

a person hanging up on me... has been very rare in real life.



There are many other things common in Movies and rare in real life.

-- A mother looks only 5 or 10 years older than her children.

-- An average person lives in an Apt/House suitable for someone 20 times richer.

-- a confidential, TOP-Secret conversation happens in a public place, like a park.

[Aidan Kehoe]

Post by HenHanna
in a movie, a guy is on the phone, and the person (on the other end)
(often a woman) hangs up
I've always felt that this happens 100+ times more
often in movies than in real life...
THEN the guy goes ...
--------- Hello? Hello? Susan? Are you there?
----------------- Did you just hang up on me?
I've always felt that this happens 1000+ times more
often in movies than in real life....

Sure. There is a long list of things that for various reasons happen much more
often in televised and film drama. Over-explication, the US winning and
achieving things completely ahistorically (see the recent Queen’s Gambit
Netflix series for this; see also a film about twenty years ago regarding the
Enigma codebreakers.) Movies are not particularly representative of real life.

Post by HenHanna
in Older movies, the guy does that [momentary Hang-up] thing.
---------- In older times, this didn't hang up?

No idea, I’m a spring chicken at 43.

[Peter Moylan]

Post by HenHanna
in a movie, a guy is on the phone, and the person (on the other
end) (often a woman) hangs up
I've always felt that this happens 100+ times more often in movies
than in real life...

Modern life has introduced a new factor. I hang up on about half a dozen
calls per day, as soon as I hear the beep that indicates that it's a
call centre. In case of doubt I wait a few seconds, and then hang up as
soon as I hear "How are you today?"

[occam]

On 12/04/2024 10:50, Aidan Kehoe wrote:
<snip>

Post by Aidan Kehoe
Sure. There is a long list of things that for various reasons happen much more
often in televised and film drama. Over-explication, the US winning and
achieving things completely ahistorically (see the recent Queen’s Gambit
Netflix series for this; see also a film about twenty years ago regarding the
Enigma codebreakers.) Movies are not particularly representative of real life.

Especially when made by Hollywood. I'm waiting for the film where US
won the war in Korea, Vietnam and Afghanistan. (Allow for 20 years for
the memory to fade.)

Post by Aidan Kehoe
in a movie, a guy is on the phone, and the person (on the other end)
(often a woman) hangs up I've always felt that this happens 100+
times more often in movies than in real life...

Don't forget, in the movie the man also looks at the handset after the
hang-up, and sneers.

There is a brilliant Netflix documentary where all these movie clichés
are documented. One that sticks in mind: "Why do women always run away
from danger in high-heels"?