Discussion:
English language is badly pronounced French
(too old to reply)
HenHanna
2024-04-10 07:09:17 UTC
Permalink
i see this Post in NovaBBS but not in TB (Thunderbird)
--------- i'm seeing this pretty often lately.


Nobody responded in 6 Hours, because (i'm guessing)
many of the AUE regulars don't see the Post ???



6 Hours 7 Minutes ago By: bertietaylor
In

the case for the English language being badly pronounced French is
explained.
I liked a comment in the comments section, mentioning that French is
badly pronounced Latin!
One view of the Ukraine war is that it results from the Ukrainian
language being badly pronounced Russian.
After from that, one may puzzle at the reason for the antagonism.
Looks like the little differences are more damaging than the big
differences.
That could explain the historical bad relations between the English
and the French after 1066. Or the violence between similar sects.
bt
HenHanna
2024-04-10 07:28:52 UTC
Permalink
i see this Post in NovaBBS  but not in TB (Thunderbird)(ES)
                    --------- i'm seeing this pretty often lately.
Nobody responded in 6 Hours, because (i'm guessing)
                    many of the AUE regulars  don't see the Post ???
6 Hours 7 Minutes ago          By: bertietaylor
In
http://youtu.be/TUL29y0vJ8Q
the case for the English language being badly pronounced French is
explained.
I liked a comment in the comments section, mentioning that French is
badly pronounced Latin!
One view of the Ukraine war is that it results from the Ukrainian
language being badly pronounced Russian.
After from that, one may puzzle at the reason for the antagonism.
Looks like the little differences are more damaging than the big
differences.
That could explain the historical bad relations between the English
and the French after 1066. Or the violence between similar sects.
bt
18-min clip... (it looks good)

RobWords ------ 444K subscribers


540,989 views Mar 30, 2024 #etymology #french #english


Enjoy this exploration of the French-ness of English. And join the
Lingoda Language Sprint to let your language skills bloom this
spring. Click my link and use my code ROBWORDS20 for 20€ off!
(Link deleted)




In this video I respond to the claim that English does not exist, but is
instead merely badly pronounced French.

I explain just how much the French have influenced our language, but why
it is still a distinct, Germanic language.



[English does not exist] seems to be a title of a French book.
HenHanna
2024-04-20 02:42:30 UTC
Permalink
i see this Post in NovaBBS  but not in TB (Thunderbird)
                    --------- i'm seeing this pretty often lately.
Nobody responded in 6 Hours, because (i'm guessing)
                    many of the AUE regulars  don't see the Post ???
6 Hours 7 Minutes ago          By: bertietaylor
In
http://youtu.be/TUL29y0vJ8Q
the case for the English language being badly pronounced French is
explained.
I liked a comment in the comments section, mentioning that French is
badly pronounced Latin!
One view of the Ukraine war is that it results from the Ukrainian
language being badly pronounced Russian.
After from that, one may puzzle at the reason for the antagonism.
Looks like the little differences are more damaging than the big
differences.
That could explain the historical bad relations between the English
and the French after 1066. Or the violence between similar sects.
bt
While the title is intentionally provocative, the book doesn't literally
claim English doesn't exist.

Here's a more nuanced understanding of the book's argument:


Historical Influence: Cerquiglini, a linguist, highlights
the significant influence of French on the development of English,
particularly after the Norman Conquest of England in 1066.


Shared Vocabulary: The book explores the vast number of
words in English with French origins, especially in areas like law,
government, and culture.


Focus on Pronunciation: Cerquiglini argues that the
pronunciation of these French-derived words has changed significantly in
English, making them seem less connected to their French roots.


The book is more of a celebration of the interconnectedness of languages
than a dismissal of English.

It emphasizes the historical and linguistic ties between French and English.
Loading...